CDO, CPO, GDPR, IAPP, Information Management and Governance, Information protection, Privacy

Data Regulation is the New Reality

On October 28th, the BBC’s Chris Baraniuk reported that recently, Tim Cook was in Brussels to address the International Conference of Data Protection and Privacy Commissioners.  In his remarks, Mr. Cook, referring to the misuse of “deeply personal” data, said data was being “weaponized against us with military efficiency”.  The BBC went on to report that Mr. Cook said “We shouldn’t sugar-coat the consequences,” and “This is surveillance.”

The speech reaffirmed Apple’s strong defense of user privacy rights, in contrast to competitors business model of driving advertising revenue by analyzing people online habits.   “The trade in personal data served only to enrich the companies that collect it, he added.”

Mr Cook also praised the EU’s new data protection regulation, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), and went on to say that other countries “including my own,” should follow the EU’s lead toward protecting personal data.

To be sure, economics are at the heart of the concern.  Given the string of events that have occured, where data is mishandled or exposed, companies are at risk of losing customer and stakeholder trust, and without that trust, it not clear how they can drive or thrive in the data economy.  So coming together in support of a GDPR-like framework makes sense; it raises the conversation to a global level, and can result in a safer and more efficient environment in which to conduct business. Companies that embrace the framework will have more flexibility and resilience, while those firms paying it lip-service will eventually themselves be at the center of their own data crisis.

And therein lies the rub.  Compliance is not the same as data protection, especially when the regulation is principles-based and not prescriptive.  If the objective in implementing a framework is to comply with a regulation, one is tempted to overlay one’s current operating model with the requirements of the regulation and address gaps.  While it may reduce the risk of data incident, it will probably do so by coincidence.

On the other hand, if companies went about handling information with the strongest possible ethics, where they routinely assessed and addressed risk, recognized and avoided moral hazards, then the incidence of breach and miss-use would naturally be much lower.

The obvious competitive issue is that the second scenario is more expensive and less flexible.  Moreover, if a minority of companies took this approach, they would be less prosperous, and economic darwinism would cause them to go extinct.  And suppose there were a major data “catastrophe”, and the market environment were made up of a combination of those that embrace a high degree of data ethics and those that don’t, the market may not recognize and reward the higher resilience of the highly-ethical-but-less-profitable.  Instead, what we’ve seen is the mainstream market reacts with shock and incredulity and – at the prompting of regulators – implement newly-penned frameworks meant to avoid future occurrences of those events.

While one might argue that black swan events are by definition unforeseeable, one can equally argue that waiting for them to strike before implementing any sort of protection strategy simply opens the door to more black swans, and when events do occur, they result in unnecessarily high impact.

Apple’s Tim Cook makes clear his view that status quo is unacceptable.  As an unquestioned highly credentialed leader and insider in the technology (and information) world, his use of words like “weaponized” and “this is surveillance” should not be taken lightly — he knows what he’s talking about.  No doubt more so than the rest of us.

So as with most things, a thoughtful balance must be considered.  The dilemma is how to balance among the following:

  1. The rapid growth the volume to data aggregated by companies, across the board from business-to-consumers, to business-to-business companies, and ranging from companies providing services to those providing goods — and the increasing overlap.

  2. As a subset of that, the increase in the volume of personal data stored online, and the ability to gather even more data about individuals – habits, interests, locations, views and opinions.

  3. The rapid evolution in the science of data analytics, and the ramp-up of technology able to manipulate and compute data on a mammoth scale.

  4. Coupled with this, is the increasing ability to combine and analyze datasets in ways that allow for the creation of new and credible data and conclusions.

  5. As the size and richness of the datasets grow, so do the consequences of an event (whether a breach, misuse, abuse or exposure).  These range from a sense of creepiness when personal data is exposed, all the way to the very real consequences of insidious manipulation of our views and opinions.

In short, how can companies derive benefit from data, while managing the risks?  Neither momentum is letting up — the momentum around utilizing the expanding datasets, or the momentum around data events and subsequent responses from regulators.

One realistic way is to embrace and build a culture around managing all aspects of data, in lock step.  This is built into a data management program, led by a Chief Data Officer, comprised of three interdependent functions:

  1. Data Leverage, focussed on enabling the business use of information,

  2. Data Protection and Compliance, focussed on addressing risk resulting from data leverage, in terms of misuse, loss or non-compliance with obligations

  3. Data Quality, ensuring that the data being used retains its accuracy and integrity

This model is coupled with appropriate oversight, in the form of:

  1. A steering group with senior stakeholders from across the company,

  2. Direct oversight by CEO or COO,

  3. Connectivity into other key functions, including the CIO, CISO, HR and Legal,

  4. Active oversight by the Board of Directors, to support business initiatives and agree with risk mitigations plans.

A standing filter for any and all data initiatives needs to be ethics, and a consideration for the consequences of the genie getting out of the lamp.  Is the company willing to handle the outcome, if an initiative goes wrong? What is the risk, how is it managed, and are the right people accepting the residual risk?

The discussion is reaching a fever pitch with leaders of the most influential technology companies adding their voices to the conversation.  Any company wanting to join the data economy should consider doing so with an appropriate data management framework. This will position them to accelerate as new opportunities present themselves, while being able to manage events as they occur and accommodate compliance requirements that arise.

 

Information Management and Governance, Information protection, Uncategorized

Data Ethics and the CDO

A wise man once told a cheeky arachnid, “With great power comes great responsibility!”

This is a particularly relevant quote in the context of the evolving data economy. CDO’s may think of themselves as caped crusaders saving mankind, and the truth is they are indeed playing an increasingly critical role to help ensure that organizations can successfully transition to their rightful place in the new data economy.

Consider the following:

  • Overwhelmingly, CEOs believe leveraging data as an asset will be more than a game-changer, and will soon become a critical differentiator to remain successful and relevant – and not all companies will make it;
  • Available data – both volume and variety – continues to grow at an impressive rate;
  • Data science and tools are moving in lock-step with the data growth, finding new ways to derive value from data, creating transformative and disruptive opportunities;
  • Data events – intrusions, breaches and exposures – are also growing at an alarming rate; in 2018 alone, hundreds of millions of people-related records have been targeted, exposed or breached (and that’s just the ones detected); and
  • Regulators – notably the EU and the State of California – are responding with complicated requirements, that will impact a great majority of organizations, and more jurisdictions will follow.

What is the role of the CDO?

The CDO’s primary responsibility is to establish the vision and execute a strategy to leverage data in a responsible way.  This ranges from monetizing data directly, through sale or licensing data, to creating new or enhancing existing products and services with data, to optimizing operations by augmenting decision-making with data.  This is a tall order, and needs to combine insights into available opportunities, maturity of the organization to embrace change, and expectations of organizational Leadership with the support they provide.  After all, if leadership isn’t on-board, a data program is not likely to be successful.

The other responsibility addresses meeting the obligations tied to the data, which starts with data ethics.   Just because we can do certain things with data, should we?  Consider some inputs to that decision:

  • Harm– As with medicine, and as the business person overseeing data initiatives, the CDO should start from the commitment to “do no harm”. The CDO should have a methodology for analyzing and socializing potential data solutions to understand the potential consequential impacts.
  • Legality– The CDO should collaborate with counsel to develop a clear understanding of where legal boundaries lie. As with “do no harm”, organizations should not break the law.  The CDO has an important role, because sometimes there is legal risk (heightened probability that a law will be – or perceived to be – broken), and analysis presented to decision-makers should be clear.  As with other cutting edge sciences, senior leadership may not be as data-literate as the CDO or the data scientists.
  • Expectations– An initiative may be “legal” – technically – and even cause no actual harm, but the organization should be comfortable that stakeholders or clients would not be so disappointed with an outcome that the organization’s brand is impacted or clients go elsewhere. A consumer-client has a different tolerance level than client-companies; consumers take reactionary queues from society, media and social-networks, often with unpredictable results.  Client companies have their own stakeholders, regulators and clients to look out for, which drive their reaction.  Moreover, an un-harmful but “creepy” initiative may draw unwanted scrutiny from a regulator, resulting in the organization expending resources to address.
  • Profit – will the initiative make money, even if risks are mitigated and obligations are met, and expectations are intact? A CDO will be presented (pitched?) with dozens of cool ideas, and has to know how to analyze them for fit within the organization. This is trickier than it seems, because data science presents data-oriented opportunities in organizations not used to the data economy.   The decision-making process around investing in a new plant or product in, say, a manufacturing company may be very different than deciding to invest in a data-driven feature or capability.  And simply “willing it to happen” isn’t enough.
  • Consequences– Suppose the organization bets wrong.  What if the initiative fails to deliver on the planned profit, or simply doesn’t work?  This is manageable through various pathways – insurance, hedges, accounting treatment, etc.  But what if the organization creates a proverbial monster?  Recent debate around AI comes to mind, with AI appearing to evolving in lab settings.  What if, in hindsight, the organization realizes they did something deeply wrong or harmful – should they have been expected to anticipate and alter course?  Recently, companies have ceased to exist because they pursued what seemed like sanctioned or low-risk data-driven initiatives, failing to anticipate social and political outrage.

The data economy presents opportunities never before available to business.  Some organizations will choose to gamble risk against profit.  Others will take a step back and forego immediate opportunities, adopting a wait-and-see attitude.  Some from each group will succeed while others fail.

Like any new science that affects humanity, data science should adopt a canon of ethics that balances achieving benefit against the risk of harm.

No doubt the CDO plays a central role in making or orchestrating decisions and administering data.  As the steward of the data vision and strategy, the CDO must be able to think through the upsides and downsides with balance and objectivity and be willing to stand behind the ethics of decisions, after the fact.

Contact me at james@jhoward.us

CDO, Information Management and Governance

CDO: Leveraging AND Protecting Data

Editor’s note: Originally published in June 2018 and refreshed in November 2026. The core argument hasn’t changed, but the stakes have.

A lot is written about the important role the CDO has in promoting, monetizing and leveraging data. There is no doubt this is a primary function, and failing to fulfill it can cost an organization revenue, competitiveness and market position. But the CDO has an equally important role in governing data, and neglecting that half of the role can lead to similarly negative outcomes.

When I first wrote this, I made a provocative statement: the data leverage market was charging ahead while the data governance disciplines were not keeping up. Eight years later, AI has pulled the two ends of that rubber band even further apart. The risks aren’t only that data is lost or breached, but that it is misused, relied on when it shouldn’t be, or never delivers its full value. The CDO plays a key role in managing that tension, and done well, it lets the organization move faster, not slower.

Let’s talk about the data

The volume keeps growing. In 2018, one estimate put the world’s data at 44 zettabytes by 2020. IDC now expects more than 274 zettabytes to be generated in 2026 alone, and most of it unstructured. Generative AI is accelerating that growth: AI models consume data, and they create more of it, in prompts, outputs, training sets and logs.

So how is it being managed?

The CDO role has gone mainstream. In 2018, fewer than one in five large companies had named a CDO. Today, around 90% of leading companies report having one, and Gartner found that 70% of chief data and analytics officers now hold primary responsibility for their organization’s AI strategy.

Frameworks have matured too, from data management standards to privacy frameworks and, more recently, AI governance standards and regulation. But they remain fragmented. Data, privacy, security and AI governance often sit with different leaders (the CDO, CPO, CISO and now the Chief AI Officer), with different priorities and limited integration. The question I raised in 2018 still stands: how can an organization position data as a key asset while also ensuring proper and proportional protection, if no one owns the whole picture?

Protection should still be proportional to data’s value, its risks and threats, and the organization’s compliance obligations. What has changed is that AI adds new dimensions: how data is used to train and run models, whether outputs are accurate and fair, and whether individuals can exercise their rights over data that now flows into systems no one fully maps.

What can go wrong?

The pattern is the same, only faster. Data is breached, questionable data is over-relied on, or momentum builds to leverage data, and now AI, without proportional governance. An event occurs, or worse, goes undetected until outsiders raise the alarm, resulting in financial and reputational damage and regulatory intervention. The headlines still lead to the same questions: “How could this have happened?” and “You should have seen that coming.”

Is it avoidable?

Black swan events are, by definition, unanticipated. But organizations can take significant steps to anticipate, avoid or prepare for them by embracing information management and governance. A data event, whether a breach or a perceived abuse of data or AI, affects not only the organization but everyone around it.

Data leverage and data governance remain opposing forces pulling at either end of the rubber band. The tension needs to be released in a controlled way, and the CDO, working closely with privacy, security and AI leaders, is well placed to do it:

  • Balance opportunity with governance. The CDO needs to be empowered to pursue value while ensuring protection, quality and accuracy.
  • Govern data and AI together. AI governance built on weak data governance inherits its weaknesses.
  • Close the gaps between roles. Whether through a combined CDO and CPO mandate or tight collaboration, someone has to see the whole picture.

We are living in a world where data is everywhere and AI multiplies what can be done with it. Forward-looking companies are looking to their CDOs to help, and those CDOs need to be properly enabled. In 2018 I said now is the time to engage. In 2026, it’s past time.